Hiring Help for Your Holiday Campaigns: Should Your Marketing Team Choose a Freelancer, an Agency or an Employee?

Pujit Siddhant

Oct 15 2026

<div class='bc_element' id='bc_element1' style='width:auto;padding:5px;max-height:100%;'><span>By fall, the marketing calendar starts filling up fast. Holiday promotions need creative, email campaigns need copy, and someone has to keep everyday work moving while seasonal activity ramps up. The people who know the business best are often the same people reviewing every draft, answering questions and taking on the increased workload. For business owners and marketing managers, hiring additional help becomes an obvious next step. Deciding what type requires a closer look at the marketing team’s needs. A freelance designer, an agency team and a full time employee bring different capabilities and require different support. Before requesting proposals or posting a job, establish what is unfinished, why it is unfinished and who will make decisions once help arrives. <b>Identify the Work and the Decisions Behind It </b><br><div>Identify the assignments for the next eight to twelve weeks. For each one, establish the deadline, required skills, available materials and person responsible for approval. Be specific about the work involved. Replace “help with holiday marketing” with assignments such as writing six promotional emails, producing product photography, adapting approved creative for paid social, updating landing pages or managing campaign reporting. Then separate a shortage of production capacity from a shortage of direction. If the campaign is approved and the team needs someone to produce assets, there is a clear starting point. If the audience, offer and budget remain unresolved, assign responsibility for those decisions before production begins. Hiring someone to make graphics will not resolve a disagreement about what the campaign should say. Examine the approval process as well. If every asset waits four days for the owner’s review, adding another producer may create a larger queue. Agree on review times, consolidate feedback and give one person authority to approve routine work. Make those arrangements before asking a provider to meet an aggressive deadline. <b><br></b></div><div><b>Choose a Freelancer for Work You Can Define and Review </b> A freelancer is a strong option when you need specific expertise for a defined period and have someone available to manage the broader campaign. Examples include designing an email series, editing product videos or auditing a paid search account. Describe the assignment through deliverables, deadlines and acceptance criteria, with clear arrangements for revisions and communication. Ask candidates to discuss comparable work. Establish what they personally handled, what inputs they received and how they dealt with changes. For an email assignment, distinguish between writing copy, designing layouts, building messages in the platform and testing them before launch. A portfolio showing polished emails does not establish that the person performed every part of that process. As the hiring manager, give the freelancer your proposed schedule and confirm that they have capacity to meet it. Agree on the start date, first review and final delivery. Specify when your team will supply materials and how late inputs will affect the schedule. Put the required source files, handoff, payment milestones and process for additional work into the agreement. Where the scope is uncertain, commission a small paid assessment or initial project before authorizing the full assignment. <b>Choose an Agency When Several Disciplines Need Coordination </b> Consider an agency when the campaign requires several connected services and you need the provider to coordinate them. A holiday launch might involve creative, landing page development, media buying and reporting. Managing separate specialists for each task takes time. An agency proposal should explain who coordinates the work and which responsibilities remain with your team. Meet the people assigned to the account, not just those presenting the proposal. Ask who develops the strategy, who produces the work, who monitors performance and who covers absences. Confirm which services are delivered internally and which are subcontracted. Review examples relevant to your budget and campaign complexity rather than relying solely on recognizable client names. Read the scope closely. Determine whether the fee includes advertising spend, production expenses, software, reporting and revisions or whether those are additional. Establish who controls advertising accounts, analytics access and campaign files during the engagement and afterward. Assign an internal contact with authority to provide timely information about inventory, pricing, customer concerns and business priorities. <b>Hire an Employee When the Work Requires Ongoing Ownership </b> An employee deserves serious consideration when the holiday workload exposes a continuing gap. If the business needs someone to manage its campaign calendar, coordinate colleagues, maintain reporting and make regular decisions after January, define that role before treating the entire need as seasonal overflow. Distinguish a permanent role from a temporary staffing need. A seasonal or part time employee may suit work requiring close supervision and a set schedule during a defined period. State the expected duration and describe any possibility of extension accurately. A permanent opportunity should only be presented when the business has a credible basis for offering one. Allow for recruiting and onboarding. Someone starting shortly before a major launch needs access, product knowledge, introductions and time to understand existing processes. Give the new hire a prioritized first week plan and a named manager. Where immediate production and ongoing ownership are both needed, a defined external assignment can support the campaign while a separate employee search proceeds. The working arrangement also has legal consequences. For federal employment tax purposes, the IRS examines behavioral control, financial control and the relationship between the parties. Calling someone a freelancer or paying against invoices does not settle their classification. Other employment laws use different standards, so review the actual arrangement under applicable federal and state requirements. <b>Compare the Cost of Completed Work </b> Compare proposals against the same brief and deadline. Include external fees or employee compensation, applicable payroll costs, tools, onboarding and the time your existing team will spend briefing, reviewing and coordinating. The SBA’s hiring guidance explains payroll and employment responsibilities that belong in the employee cost assessment. For illustration, a $4,000 freelance proposal requiring substantial internal coordination and a $6,000 agency proposal including project management are not directly comparable. Establish what each delivers and which tasks your team will still be required to manage. A higher fee needs to be supported by work, expertise or coordination that is valuable to your business. Examine the delivery schedule with the same care. Ask how the provider will meet the deadline, which materials you must supply and which steps require a fixed amount of time. An immediate start has limited value if account access, product information or approvals will take another week. <b>Agree on Quality, AI Use and the Final Handoff </b> Before production starts, define what “ready” means. An email needs more than approved copy: links, offers, audience selection and display testing require attention. A landing page needs a functioning form and appropriate measurement. Assign responsibility for those checks and identify who authorizes publication or spending. Discuss AI use where it affects the assignment. Ask whether customer information or confidential material will enter external tools, how generated claims will be checked and who reviews the final output. Expect the provider to explain and stand behind the work. Faster production still needs to meet the agreed standards. Schedule the handoff before the engagement ends. Require organized files, appropriate account access, outstanding task notes and a record of what ran and what the team learned. For an employee, build that documentation into normal work. For a freelancer or agency, specify the required handover in the scope. <b>WorkTote Takeaway </b> For employers, the key question is what someone’s experience demonstrates. Relevant projects, tools, responsibilities and working preferences offer a clearer picture of what a candidate can do. Evaluate that information against the actual work, level of autonomy and decisions the role requires. WorkTote helps candidates showcase a more complete picture of their professional experience through projects, skills, tools, certifications and past responsibilities. Employers can use these details to identify relevant experience and ask more targeted interview questions. Knowing a candidate has used an email platform is a starting point; seeing a project description that explains how they built, tested and improved a campaign gives the interview a specific contribution to examine. For candidates pursuing holiday work, make your contribution explicit. State which parts of a campaign you owned, the tools you used and how you handled deadlines and feedback. That helps an employer distinguish a specialist suited to a defined assignment from someone prepared to take broader responsibility, making expectations clearer before either side commits. <i><b>Sources </b> <b>Internal Revenue Service</b>: <a href="https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc762?utm_source=https://tote.work">Topic 762, Independent Contractor vs. Employee</a>. <b>U.S. Department of Labor</b>: <a href="https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/flsa/misclassification/myths/detail?utm_source=https://tote.work">Myths About Misclassification</a>. <b>U.S. Small Business Administration</b>: <a href="https://legacy.sba.gov/business-guide/manage-your-business/hire-manage-employees?utm_source=https://tote.work">Hire and Manage Employees</a>.</i></div><span></div>

Other stories

Powered by

RADAR108